Fresh water from a well in the sea at Rameswaram

In Rameswaram, an Island on the South east coast of India, there is a well some distance into the sea that provides water which is not salty and can be drunk. This is  a holy place and according to Hindu mythology Lord Rama shot an arrow into the sea to get water to drink for his wife Sita. This is known as the Villundi Tīrtham well.  How is it possible that you get non-salty water amid the sea water?

The Earth has Oceans which occur in “basins”. Continents, that is land we live on, is higher than the water level in the Oceans. (If you are keen for more, read about Isostasy.)

On land, groundwater occurs beneath the surface in what geologists call as Aquifers. Aquifers are geologic formations that can store and transmit water. Note that geologic formations are rock strata that have similar properties (for example rocks of a certain chemical and mineral nature is one such property). These have been deposited over millions of years (if you are interested read about stratigraphy, erosion, landforms, geologic time, etc).

Under some instances water gets collected from rain, rivers, and other sources and is stored underground in aquifers.

Aquifers constantly interact with other water sources, atmosphere, and is governed by forces such as pressure and gravity. The geologic formations too determine the aquifer’s nature – porosity, permeability, storage capacity, etc.

Groundwater near the coast interacts with the sea water too. The figure (source: Solinst) shows theoretically how groundwater exists. In reality though it is very complex.

Groundwater is recharged by rain and lakes or rivers. Thus Groundwater is not stagnant and flows. The flow is described by Darcy’s law which in simple terms means “groundwater flows depending on pressure and the length of the aquifer medium”. This pressure is the reason we are able to dig wells. This is often the capillary pressure.

Groundwater can be confined within strata and be under pressure. Or it may not have a confining layer and could be seen close to the surface.

The level to which groundwater can raise is the water table. Of course this is only for groundwater that is not confined by impervious or semi impervious strata. The potentiomentric surface is used to describe the water table level.

On the coasts, groundwater exists in “dynamic and often transient equilibrium” with sea water. Sea water is denser and filtrates into the ground beneath the sea and on to the land.

Groundwater should flow – discharge into the sea – as long as the water table level is at a higher pressure gradient. Sea water in turn will try to flow in and contaminate the fresh groundwater. There is a seawater-freshwater interface (not a sharp line!) that is transient and keeps changing with rainfall, river or lake discharge, tides and evaporation.

If humans pump out water from the coastal areas, sea water intrudes the fresher groundwater. The Gyben-Herzberg equation governs the fresher groundwater aquifer-sea water interface. For every feet of water on the surface, some 40 feet of groundwater exists below sea level.

So what does it have to do with this freshwater well in the sea? If you dig a well in the sea you expect to get saline water. Yet, the well provides drinkable water because of these possible scenarios:- the freshwater-sea water interface extends far into the sea even beneath the waves. Highly unlikely as the water table pressure would need to be immensely high on the land!
– there is submarine discharge of groundwater from a confined aquifer beneath the sea at this place. The strata confining the aquifer prevents water from seeping out on the land side but there is a hidden interface on the sea side.This is possible.
– maybe seawater has “transgressed” only on the surface and below the surface is stopped from infiltering by impervious formations.

So this must be some kind of mix of these situations. The sea water here is pretty static – no waves in sight. Modeling coastal aquifers is a major headache. On Islands, the Fetter analytical solution applies better. I will not describe that here.

Usually, salt water intrusion into coastal aquifers is due to:

– lateral movement of salt water from the sea due to heavy water loss (withdrawals by humans) from the coastal aquifers
– “Saline zones” deep in the interface move up to cause “upconing” near coastal pumping wells

So is it possible? Yes. Fresh water is less denser than salt water and “floats” on salt water. This is important when you bore into the groundwater in islands. Rain water percolates into the ground and pushes the salt water beneath it. So you need to model the interface where freshwater and saltwater mix and take care not to disturb this by puncturing into sea water (when you drill).

Here is a citation that explains why this well gives freshwater:

“This natural movement of fresh water towards the sea prevents salt water from entering freshwater coastal aquifers (Barlow, 2003).”

Similar examples exist at Cuba and the Gulf of Mexico.

There are 22 wells in the Rameswaram temple – on a shallow coastal aquifer (unconfined) and close to the sea. The dissolved solids vary in each.

So even if shooting the arrow part is not an acceptable theory, one must note the intelligence behind these wells. There was no technology and yet, this well was predicted to yield non-salty water.

2 responses

  1. I’m watching an episode of The Nature of Things tonight and they are discussing the draught in California. An eye opening episode. My question is why can’t salt water from the ocean be piped into large reservoirs inland. Wouldn’t the ground under filter out the salt and fill the aquifer with fresh water?

    1. Great question but salt is not easily filtered – it takes time. Aquifers were formed by nature over eons. And usually when aquifers are drained out, the damage is irreversible usually. They do managed aquifer recharge especially in Perth, Australia but Chloride is a problem. See this nice article on the difficulties of just moving seawater into aquifers: http://ask.metafilter.com/286325/What-would-the-pitfalls-be-of-pumping-sea-water-inland-to-refill-aquifer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Volcanism Blog

volcanoes, volcanism and volcanology

Written In Stone...seen through my lens

A passion for Geology...active after a hiatus

Magma Cum Laude

By Jessica Ball

Arizona Geology

A passion for Geology...active after a hiatus

Blog - Agile

A passion for Geology...active after a hiatus

Highly Allochthonous

A passion for Geology...active after a hiatus

AGU Blogosphere | Site-Wide Activity

A passion for Geology...active after a hiatus

Letters from Gondwana.

Paleontology, books and other stuff.

The Failed Rift

Gist from a triple-junction.

Rock-Head Sciences

A science blog that brings you closer to the world of geology! Featuring the "A Day in the GeoLife" and "GeoProject" guest blog series from geoscientists around the world.

verseherder

Birding in south India and life on planet earth

Elaine R. Smid

Volcanologist. Erupting at you from the City of Volcanoes.

Anisotropic Reflections

interpretations of a geological geophysicist

Ancient Shore

Paleontology, Geology, and Landscape

The Trembling Earth

now at blogs.agu.org/tremblingearth

%d bloggers like this: